Carthage A History eBook Ð Carthage A Kindle -

5 thoughts on “Carthage A History

  1. Nathan Albright Nathan Albright says:

    But is it a history?  There is no doubt that I would enjoy reading a good narrative history of Carthage if it could be found but this book is heavy on archaeology heavy on discussion about digs and about those who have written about Carthage and key moments of its history and not as much of a history as one would hope  Indeed this book is an apology for the difficulties of writing a history about Carthage than it is a history itself  Given that the author has written other works mostly in French concerning the archaeology of Carthage it is little surprise that he focuses so much on what he knows namely artifacts and does not focus on what readers would want from this work which is a coherent narrative that provides some well supported discussions of important aspects of Carthage's history such as its government its material culture and its language and religion  And to be sure the author covers at least some of this material albeit in a tentative way that is not very narrative and not very enjoyable to read  This is a book that does not reward its reader unless you like reading about things and stuff and about sites and how they are uncovered rather than about the history of a largely obscure ancient civilization as the book promises in its misleading titleThis book of roughly 450 pages consists of 11 mostly long chapters  The author begins with a discussion of the founding of Carthage 1 where the author spends much time examining myths and looking at the dating of material remains and issues with the texts  After that there is a discussion of the establishment of the city 2 and here too the author focuses on grave goods and tombs which are most of what has been uncovered in the city itself  Then follows a discussion of the beginnings of empire which looks at early Punic sites and artifacts in the Western Mediterranean basin 3  The author discusses the move from a thalassocracy to a state and here too we look at a shipwreck 4  There is a discussion of the development of the city from the fifth century to its destruction in 146 BC 5 and this involves a look at town planning and the arrangement of harbors and houses  A discussion of religion involves a lot of discussion of the excavation of tophets and the large amount of infants and small children found with calcified bones who were likely victims of burnt child sacrifice 6  The author talks about the expansion of Carthage's rule into Africa and here are discussions of rural residences and other material remains of Carthage's power 7  Even a discussion of Carthage's ambiguous position between east and west 8 involves architecture sculpture and other material culture  The discussion of Carthage and Rome's imperial competition is one of the most narrative aspects of the book but it comes rather late 9 and is followed by a discussion of the final ordeal of the city during the Third Punic War and late punic pottery 10  The author then closes with a discussion of the double survival of Carthage's culture and language under Roman rule 11 after which there is a chronological overview bibliographic notes and an indexThis book has a lot of interesting photos and drawings and details about archaeological digs and material remains including masks and statues and pottery and grave goods and lonely fortresses and maps  But is it a history?  I'm not sure if most of this work ualifies as a history and I suppose readers will have to judge for themselves if this is the sort of historical work they can approve of  It is easy enough to recognize that the history of Carthage presents major difficulties that there are some serious conflicts between text and material remains and it is clear that the author has an anti textual bias even if he openly admits that the high amount of consistently built up area in the core of the city of Carthage itself means that few material remains are going to survive from antiuity as much as one may want to find them  As someone who reads a fair amount about the phenomenon of biblical architecture the author's disdain for texts and his open preference for sometimes dubious interpretations of material culture in exchange of a thoughtful understanding of written texts that can form the basis of a sensible chronological narrative make this book less enjoyable to read than it would have been had it been written by a competent author with a better methodological approach to the writing of history

  2. Stephan Frank Stephan Frank says:

    Very brief comments Clearly a very in depth scholarly report on what was at the time of the books' writing known about Carthage rather than a mere history of the famous cityMost interesting aspect for me how little solid archaeological evidence there really appears to be which since then may have changed When thinking about that a little it becomes a little obvious due to the vast destruction laid upon their bitter rival by the Romans who basically tried to wipe out evidence of the very existence of that city

  3. Alcibiades Alcibiades says:

    I read the French version of the book It is the best history book on Carthage Serge Lancel is a historian and an archeologist who specializes in Carthage He spent decades researching this topic on sites and in academia His book in Hannibal is also une œuvre d'art Irremplaçable

  4. AskHistorians AskHistorians says:

    It goes from the founding of the city to its destruction using archeology and literary sources to back up his findings noting where a topic isn't conclusive and presents us with the evidence so as the reader can make their own conclusions such as the child sacrifice debate

  5. Monica Sortino Monica Sortino says:

    This book was informative and really interesting However translation from academic French into English made it even denser than it would be normally

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Carthage A History Carthage A History by BH Warmington Carthage A History by BH Warmington Rating details ratings reviews It is many years since a book about ancient Carthage appeared in this country in spite of the fact that Carthage played a major part in the history of Rome and of the Greek colonies in Sicily I Carthage A History by Serge Lancel Carthage A History by Serge Lancel Antonia Nevill Translator Rating details ratings reviews Carthage now a ruin on the north coast of Africa was the capital of one of the ancient world's most powerful empires Get A Copy ; Stores Libraries; Paperback pages Published July th by Wiley Blackwell first published June th More Details HISTORY OF CARTHAGE HISTORY OF CARTHAGE including Dido's city Colonies and rivals The Punic Wars Colonia Julia Carthago Vandals in Carthage The last years Carthage A little bit of History | Pearltrees Ancient Carthage Ancient Carthage from Phoenician 𐤒𐤓𐤕 𐤇𐤃𐤔𐤕 art ḥadašt was a Semitic civilization centered on the Phoenician city state of Carthage located in North Africa on the Gulf of Tunis outside what is now Tunis Tunisia Serge Lancel Carthage a history Translated by Serge Lancel Carthage a history Translated by Antonia Nevill xvii pp Oxford Blackwell Volume Issue J C L Gibson Social Sciences Carthage A History Carthage A History Carthage is one of the most evocative Mediterranean sites Its eventsand characters wrapped up in Roman literature a Carthage Vae victis | Alternative History | Fandom Carthage was a monarchy in Libya that existed between BC and AD During this time it was a major trading hub and military power It was highly influential across Europe and Ethiopia At several times during its existence it had a near monopoly on trade in the Mediterranean and massive political control over its neighbors This would make it one of the richest and longest lasting CARTHAGE La campagne internationale de fouilles Il faut sauver Carthage A Carthage l'intensification des fouilles archologiues apparat comme un enjeu prioritaire A Short Basic History of Carthage | History Forum Ill be sure to try My main interest is Hannibal himself Carthage comes second but it is hugely fascinating I could write one on his use of propaganda Archdiocese of Carthage Wikipedia The Archdiocese of Carthage also known as the Church of Carthage was a Latin Catholic diocese established in Carthage Roman Empire in the nd century Agrippin was the first named bishop around AD The temporal importance of the city of Carthage in the Roman Empire had previously been restored by Julius Caesar and AugustusWhen Christianity became firmly established around the

  • Paperback
  • 496 pages
  • Carthage A History
  • Serge Lancel
  • English
  • 18 July 2016
  • 9781577181033